Learn about customs valuation with answers to FAQs. Understand methods, legal frameworks, and tips for accurate declarations in international trade.
What is the primary goal of the WTO Agreement on Customs Valuation, and how does it relate to the GATT?
The primary goal of the WTO Agreement on Customs Valuation is to establish a fair, neutral, and uniform system for determining the customs value of goods traded internationally. It is a rules-based system designed to facilitate trade by ensuring that valuation practices are transparent and equitable. This agreement is rooted in Article VII of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and evolved from the GATT Valuation Code established in 1981. The WTO agreement on customs valuation became a mandatory agreement for all WTO members in 1995, superseding previous systems such as the Brussels Definition of Value (BDV).
What is the Transaction Value method, and why is it the preferred approach for customs valuation?
The Transaction Value (TV) method is the primary method for determining customs value, used in approximately 95% of cases. It is based on the “price actually paid or payable” for the imported goods, reflecting the commercial reality of the buy-sell transaction. This price includes all payments made or to be made as a condition of the sale, whether to the seller or a third party benefiting the seller. The TV method is preferred because it is considered to best represent commercial reality and is based on simple, equitable criteria. The price must be established in circumstances that comply with GATT principles.
What are some specific costs or payments that are included in the “price actually paid or payable” under the Transaction Value method?
The “price actually paid or payable” includes all payments made or to be made as a condition of sale. This may include: Payments made directly to the seller; Payments made to a third party for the benefit of the seller; Payments made to a third party related to the seller; Payments made to a third party to satisfy an obligation of the seller. Payments can be made directly, indirectly, via letters of credit, or with other negotiable instruments. The total payment is not necessarily the invoice value and can include advance payments or other indirect payments so long as they are a condition of the sale.
What are some common costs or payments that can be excluded from the customs value under the Transaction Value method?
Several costs can be excluded if they are separately identified and not for the benefit of the seller. This includes delivery costs within the country of importation, post-importation work (like assembly or maintenance), and interest charges under a written financing arrangement. Additionally, payments for the right to reproduce goods in the country of importation, buying agent commissions, and duties and taxes of the country of importation can be excluded. It is also possible to exclude costs related to marketing activities performed by the buyer on their own account (not for the benefit of the seller).
What are ‘assists’ in customs valuation, and how are they treated in the calculation of the Transaction Value?
“Assists” are goods or services provided by the buyer, either free of charge or at a reduced cost, to the seller for use in the production of the imported goods. They include materials, tools, components, and engineering/design work (if done outside the country of importation). If assists are supplied by the buyer to the seller, their value must be added to the price actually paid or payable. The value of these assists is typically the full value, reduced value, acquisition cost or production cost. This value includes transportation costs to the place of manufacture, import and export clearance charges, and any duties and taxes not refunded.
What are the alternative methods of customs valuation if the Transaction Value method cannot be used?
If the Transaction Value (Method 1) cannot be applied, alternative methods must be used in a fixed sequence: (1) Transaction Value of Identical Goods, (2) Transaction Value of Similar Goods, (3) Deductive Method, (4) Computed Method, and (5) the Fallback Method. The order of the Deductive and Computed methods may be reversed at the importer’s request. These methods are used sequentially because each aims to find the next best approximation of value based on real-world sales or production information, using “identical” or “similar” goods if the value cannot be taken directly from a real sale of the goods in question.
What are some key situations or “limitations” that would prevent the use of the Transaction Value method?
There are several situations where the TV cannot be used. These limitations include: (1) No sale for export to the country of importation has occurred. (2) The price does not meet four basic conditions: no restrictions on the buyer’s use of the goods, sale not subject to undetermined conditions, no accrual of resale proceeds to the seller, and the buyer and seller are not related, or, if related, the relationship did not influence the price. (3) Adjustments to the price cannot be supported by objective data. (4) The customs officials have reason to doubt the accuracy of the declaration. These limitations ensure that the value is reliable and not distorted by non-commercial conditions.
How does customs ensure compliance and transparency in the valuation process, and what are the consequences of non-compliance?
Customs administrations are required to operate using clear and precise rules that are legally based, and must provide written explanations of their valuation determinations to importers when rejecting declared values. Customs audits assess the quality and accuracy of declarations and invoices. The release of goods can be secured through bank guarantees pending dispute resolutions. Failure to correctly follow valuation rules, particularly deliberate undervaluation to avoid customs duties, can result in severe sanctions, including high fines, seizure of goods, and even imprisonment. Additionally, duties will be assessed based on any revised customs values determined by customs authorities.
Comments